Overstating trophic cascade strength following large carnivore restoration in Yellowstone: A comment on Painter et al. (2025) Article Swipe

PDF

Daniel R. MacNulty , Elaine M. Brice , Normand Bergeron , Eric J. Larsen ·

YOU? · · 2025 · Open Access · · DOI: https://doi.org/10.32942/x2w949

Painter et al. (2025) claim that large-carnivore recovery in Yellowstone National Park has produced a strong trophic cascade compared to other systems, citing a 152 fold increase in aspen sapling density and widespread recruitment of new trees. We show that these conclusions substantially overstate the cascade’s strength because of key methodological and interpretive flaws. First, Painter et al. miscalculated the baseline density in their dataset, inflating the reported log response ratio from a true 17.5 fold increase to 152 fold. Second, they analyzed repeated measurements of the same stands as if they were independent samples, overstating standardized effect sizes by 30–40%. Third, because sapling densities are highly zero-inflated and right-skewed, mean-based metrics (log response ratios and standardized differences) are disproportionately influenced by a small minority of plots, while most plots showed little or no change. Fourth, Painter et al. conflated stand-level occurrence with magnitude, treating the presence of one or a few tall stems (“43% of stands contained small trees”) as evidence of widespread recruitment. Finally, their assumptions that stems ≥ 2 m have escaped browsing and that reduced browsing alone drives height growth are contradicted by long-term data showing substantial browsing through 2–2.5 m and strong height–browsing feedbacks. Taken together, these shortcomings exaggerate the magnitude and pace of aspen recovery. The evidence supports the occurrence of a trophic cascade in Yellowstone, but not the magnitude of strength claimed. Accurate assessment of trophic cascade strength in Yellowstone is vital to ensure that this iconic system reliably informs ecological understanding and restoration practice.

Related Topics

Truth And Reconciliation Commission Of Canada

Reich Ministry Of Public Enlightenment And Propaganda

Concepts

No concepts available.

Metadata

Type: preprint
Landing Page: https://doi.org/10.32942/x2w949
PDF: https://ecoevorxiv.org/repository/object/10699/download/19639/
OA Status: gold
OpenAlex ID: https://openalex.org/W4415769593

All OpenAlex metadata

Raw OpenAlex JSON

OpenAlex ID: https://openalex.org/W4415769593

Canonical identifier for this work in OpenAlex
DOI: https://doi.org/10.32942/x2w949

Digital Object Identifier
Title: Overstating trophic cascade strength following large carnivore restoration in Yellowstone: A comment on Painter et al. (2025)

Work title
Type: preprint

OpenAlex work type
Publication year: 2025

Year of publication
Publication date: 2025-11-02

Full publication date if available
Authors: Daniel R. MacNulty, Elaine M. Brice, Normand Bergeron, Eric J. Larsen

List of authors in order
Landing page: https://doi.org/10.32942/x2w949

Publisher landing page
PDF URL: https://ecoevorxiv.org/repository/object/10699/download/19639/

Direct link to full text PDF
Open access: Yes

Whether a free full text is available
OA status: gold

Open access status per OpenAlex
OA URL: https://ecoevorxiv.org/repository/object/10699/download/19639/

Direct OA link when available
Cited by: 0

Total citation count in OpenAlex

Full payload

id	https://openalex.org/W4415769593
doi	https://doi.org/10.32942/x2w949
ids.doi	https://doi.org/10.32942/x2w949
ids.openalex	https://openalex.org/W4415769593
fwci
type	preprint
title	Overstating trophic cascade strength following large carnivore restoration in Yellowstone: A comment on Painter et al. (2025)
biblio.issue
biblio.volume
biblio.last_page
biblio.first_page
is_xpac	False
apc_list
apc_paid
language
locations[0].id	doi:10.32942/x2w949
locations[0].is_oa	True
locations[0].source
locations[0].license	cc-by
locations[0].pdf_url	https://ecoevorxiv.org/repository/object/10699/download/19639/
locations[0].version	acceptedVersion
locations[0].raw_type	posted-content
locations[0].license_id	https://openalex.org/licenses/cc-by
locations[0].is_accepted	True
locations[0].is_published	False
locations[0].raw_source_name
locations[0].landing_page_url	https://doi.org/10.32942/x2w949
indexed_in	crossref
authorships[0].author.id	https://openalex.org/A5065838882
authorships[0].author.orcid	https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9173-8910
authorships[0].author.display_name	Daniel R. MacNulty
authorships[0].author_position	first
authorships[0].raw_author_name	Daniel MacNulty
authorships[0].is_corresponding	False
authorships[1].author.id	https://openalex.org/A5077009568
authorships[1].author.orcid	https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6034-4065
authorships[1].author.display_name	Elaine M. Brice
authorships[1].author_position	middle
authorships[1].raw_author_name	Elaine Brice
authorships[1].is_corresponding	False
authorships[2].author.id	https://openalex.org/A5065877690
authorships[2].author.orcid	https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2413-6810
authorships[2].author.display_name	Normand Bergeron
authorships[2].author_position	middle
authorships[2].raw_author_name	Nicholas Bergeron
authorships[2].is_corresponding	False
authorships[3].author.id	https://openalex.org/A5024246843
authorships[3].author.orcid
authorships[3].author.display_name	Eric J. Larsen
authorships[3].author_position	last
authorships[3].raw_author_name	Eric Larsen
authorships[3].is_corresponding	False
has_content.pdf	True
has_content.grobid_xml	False
is_paratext	False
open_access.is_oa	True
open_access.oa_url	https://ecoevorxiv.org/repository/object/10699/download/19639/
open_access.oa_status	gold
open_access.any_repository_has_fulltext	False
created_date	2025-11-02T00:00:00
display_name	Overstating trophic cascade strength following large carnivore restoration in Yellowstone: A comment on Painter et al. (2025)
has_fulltext	False
is_retracted	False
updated_date	2025-11-06T03:46:38.306776
primary_topic
cited_by_count	0
locations_count	1
best_oa_location.id	doi:10.32942/x2w949
best_oa_location.is_oa	True
best_oa_location.source
best_oa_location.license	cc-by
best_oa_location.pdf_url	https://ecoevorxiv.org/repository/object/10699/download/19639/
best_oa_location.version	acceptedVersion
best_oa_location.raw_type	posted-content
best_oa_location.license_id	https://openalex.org/licenses/cc-by
best_oa_location.is_accepted	True
best_oa_location.is_published	False
best_oa_location.raw_source_name
best_oa_location.landing_page_url	https://doi.org/10.32942/x2w949
primary_location.id	doi:10.32942/x2w949
primary_location.is_oa	True
primary_location.source
primary_location.license	cc-by
primary_location.pdf_url	https://ecoevorxiv.org/repository/object/10699/download/19639/
primary_location.version	acceptedVersion
primary_location.raw_type	posted-content
primary_location.license_id	https://openalex.org/licenses/cc-by
primary_location.is_accepted	True
primary_location.is_published	False
primary_location.raw_source_name
primary_location.landing_page_url	https://doi.org/10.32942/x2w949
publication_date	2025-11-02
publication_year	2025
referenced_works_count	0
abstract_inverted_index.2	171
abstract_inverted_index.a	14, 23, 72, 122, 150, 217
abstract_inverted_index.m	172, 194
abstract_inverted_index.We	37
abstract_inverted_index.as	89, 160
abstract_inverted_index.by	99, 121, 186
abstract_inverted_index.et	1, 56, 137
abstract_inverted_index.if	90
abstract_inverted_index.in	8, 27, 62, 220, 235
abstract_inverted_index.is	237
abstract_inverted_index.no	133
abstract_inverted_index.of	34, 48, 85, 125, 147, 155, 162, 208, 216, 226, 231
abstract_inverted_index.or	132, 149
abstract_inverted_index.to	19, 77, 239
abstract_inverted_index.152	24, 78
abstract_inverted_index.The	211
abstract_inverted_index.al.	2, 57, 138
abstract_inverted_index.and	31, 51, 108, 115, 176, 195, 206, 249
abstract_inverted_index.are	105, 118, 184
abstract_inverted_index.but	222
abstract_inverted_index.few	151
abstract_inverted_index.has	12
abstract_inverted_index.key	49
abstract_inverted_index.log	68
abstract_inverted_index.new	35
abstract_inverted_index.not	223
abstract_inverted_index.one	148
abstract_inverted_index.the	44, 59, 66, 86, 145, 204, 214, 224
abstract_inverted_index.≥	170
abstract_inverted_index.(log	112
abstract_inverted_index.17.5	74
abstract_inverted_index.Park	11
abstract_inverted_index.data	188
abstract_inverted_index.fold	25, 75
abstract_inverted_index.from	71
abstract_inverted_index.have	173
abstract_inverted_index.most	128
abstract_inverted_index.pace	207
abstract_inverted_index.same	87
abstract_inverted_index.show	38
abstract_inverted_index.tall	152
abstract_inverted_index.that	5, 39, 168, 177, 241
abstract_inverted_index.they	81, 91
abstract_inverted_index.this	242
abstract_inverted_index.true	73
abstract_inverted_index.were	92
abstract_inverted_index.with	142
abstract_inverted_index.Taken	199
abstract_inverted_index.alone	180
abstract_inverted_index.aspen	28, 209
abstract_inverted_index.claim	4
abstract_inverted_index.fold.	79
abstract_inverted_index.other	20
abstract_inverted_index.plots	129
abstract_inverted_index.ratio	70
abstract_inverted_index.sizes	98
abstract_inverted_index.small	123, 158
abstract_inverted_index.stems	153, 169
abstract_inverted_index.their	63, 166
abstract_inverted_index.these	40, 201
abstract_inverted_index.vital	238
abstract_inverted_index.while	127
abstract_inverted_index.(2025)	3
abstract_inverted_index.First,	54
abstract_inverted_index.Third,	101
abstract_inverted_index.citing	22
abstract_inverted_index.drives	181
abstract_inverted_index.effect	97
abstract_inverted_index.ensure	240
abstract_inverted_index.flaws.	53
abstract_inverted_index.growth	183
abstract_inverted_index.height	182
abstract_inverted_index.highly	106
abstract_inverted_index.iconic	243
abstract_inverted_index.little	131
abstract_inverted_index.plots,	126
abstract_inverted_index.ratios	114
abstract_inverted_index.showed	130
abstract_inverted_index.stands	88, 156
abstract_inverted_index.strong	15, 196
abstract_inverted_index.system	244
abstract_inverted_index.trees.	36
abstract_inverted_index.(“43%	154
abstract_inverted_index.2–2.5	193
abstract_inverted_index.Fourth,	135
abstract_inverted_index.Painter	0, 55, 136
abstract_inverted_index.Second,	80
abstract_inverted_index.because	47, 102
abstract_inverted_index.cascade	17, 219, 233
abstract_inverted_index.change.	134
abstract_inverted_index.density	30, 61
abstract_inverted_index.escaped	174
abstract_inverted_index.informs	246
abstract_inverted_index.metrics	111
abstract_inverted_index.reduced	178
abstract_inverted_index.sapling	29, 103
abstract_inverted_index.showing	189
abstract_inverted_index.through	192
abstract_inverted_index.trophic	16, 218, 232
abstract_inverted_index.Accurate	229
abstract_inverted_index.Finally,	165
abstract_inverted_index.National	10
abstract_inverted_index.analyzed	82
abstract_inverted_index.baseline	60
abstract_inverted_index.browsing	175, 179, 191
abstract_inverted_index.claimed.	228
abstract_inverted_index.compared	18
abstract_inverted_index.dataset,	64
abstract_inverted_index.evidence	161, 212
abstract_inverted_index.increase	26, 76
abstract_inverted_index.minority	124
abstract_inverted_index.presence	146
abstract_inverted_index.produced	13
abstract_inverted_index.recovery	7
abstract_inverted_index.reliably	245
abstract_inverted_index.repeated	83
abstract_inverted_index.reported	67
abstract_inverted_index.response	69, 113
abstract_inverted_index.samples,	94
abstract_inverted_index.strength	46, 227, 234
abstract_inverted_index.supports	213
abstract_inverted_index.systems,	21
abstract_inverted_index.treating	144
abstract_inverted_index.30–40%.	100
abstract_inverted_index.conflated	139
abstract_inverted_index.contained	157
abstract_inverted_index.densities	104
abstract_inverted_index.inflating	65
abstract_inverted_index.long-term	187
abstract_inverted_index.magnitude	205, 225
abstract_inverted_index.overstate	43
abstract_inverted_index.practice.	251
abstract_inverted_index.recovery.	210
abstract_inverted_index.together,	200
abstract_inverted_index.trees”)	159
abstract_inverted_index.assessment	230
abstract_inverted_index.ecological	247
abstract_inverted_index.exaggerate	203
abstract_inverted_index.feedbacks.	198
abstract_inverted_index.influenced	120
abstract_inverted_index.magnitude,	143
abstract_inverted_index.mean-based	110
abstract_inverted_index.occurrence	141, 215
abstract_inverted_index.widespread	32, 163
abstract_inverted_index.Yellowstone	9, 236
abstract_inverted_index.assumptions	167
abstract_inverted_index.cascade’s	45
abstract_inverted_index.conclusions	41
abstract_inverted_index.independent	93
abstract_inverted_index.overstating	95
abstract_inverted_index.recruitment	33
abstract_inverted_index.restoration	250
abstract_inverted_index.stand-level	140
abstract_inverted_index.substantial	190
abstract_inverted_index.Yellowstone,	221
abstract_inverted_index.contradicted	185
abstract_inverted_index.differences)	117
abstract_inverted_index.interpretive	52
abstract_inverted_index.measurements	84
abstract_inverted_index.recruitment.	164
abstract_inverted_index.shortcomings	202
abstract_inverted_index.standardized	96, 116
abstract_inverted_index.miscalculated	58
abstract_inverted_index.right-skewed,	109
abstract_inverted_index.substantially	42
abstract_inverted_index.understanding	248
abstract_inverted_index.zero-inflated	107
abstract_inverted_index.methodological	50
abstract_inverted_index.large-carnivore	6
abstract_inverted_index.height–browsing	197
abstract_inverted_index.disproportionately	119
cited_by_percentile_year
countries_distinct_count	0
institutions_distinct_count	4
citation_normalized_percentile